Create an Account - Increase your productivity, customize your experience, and engage in information you care about.
Posted on July 2, 2019 at 7:21 PM by Annette Braun
Unless you’re a juice up horse with a needle in your butt, you don’t need to spend two hours in the gym to maximize efficiency. Once you trigger muscle protein synthesis, it’s time to leave the gym. The idea that a natural lifter needs 20 sets of 5 different exercises all targeting the same muscle group is misguided time wasting. In an effort to save the natural lifter time and energy, I’m going to pick two exercises for the lower body. I will try my best to avoid choosing the same exercise in two different muscle slots. Five categories will be considered: quadriceps, hamstrings, glutes, hip adductors, and hip flexors. Exercises will be evaluated by their electromyographical (EMG) amplitude. EMG is recorded by placing electrodes on muscle groups in an effort to record electrical impulses. EMG can be described as the study of electricity in muscles. More specifically, EMG amplitude is a measure of motor unit activity during muscle action. It’s described as an evaluation of muscle tension or how hard a muscle becomes during exercise. EMG comes with a set of limitations: cross talk, interference, placement error, muscle fatigue, technique, etc. Researchers plan for this and typically make every effort to avoid these limitations.
For the hamstrings, I chose the two handed kettlebell swing and the deadlift. The prone leg curl was not chosen because the activity doesn’t mechanically represent a normal pattern of motion: the difficult portion of the lift shortens the hamstring, which is the opposite in the case of the deadlift or squat or jump. Also, the eccentric (easy) part of the RDL has extremely high hamstring EMG activity when compared to the prone leg curl.
The hamstring group is comprised of three muscles. The group lies behind or posteriorly to the femur. The biceps femoris (BF) lies posteriorly and laterally to the femur. The semitendinosus (ST) lies medially to the femur. Finally, the semimembranosus (SM) will not be discussed as it is difficult to use surface EMG data to evaluate the muscle.
If I were to choose one exercise for the rest of my life, I would choose the deadlift. It has numerous applications in activities of daily living. It involves the most muscle groups of the powerlifts: core, quads, hamstrings, calves, adductors, hips, upper and lower back, and forearms. It can be loaded progressively. It has a plethora of variations. It’s the foundation of the olympic lifts. In one study, the conventional deadlift outperformed the romanian deadlift in the three categories analysed: gluteus maximus (GMax), rectus femoris (RF) , and BF . Another study found the sumo deadlift had significantly more knee extensor activity than the conventional deadlift . The study also found that the BF and ST activity was slightly higher in the sumo deadlift, although not significantly. What’s more interesting is the activity of the core muscles, which were highly activated in both sumo and conventional variations. On this basis, it may be surmised the sumo is the best variation of deadlift in terms of total muscle activation, followed by conventional and lastly the romanian version [20, 21]. Although the deadlift is one of the best ways to involve a myriad of muscle groups, it has its drawbacks. One drawback is the shearing forces applied to the spine and the potential to over activate the erector spinae. Another drawback is the extremely technical nature of the exercise and its many variations. The spine must be neutral: not overly extended or flexed. One must pull into the bar to set the scapulae (shoulder blades) and prepare the glutes and hamstrings before any lift is attempted. The initial drive comes from the legs and the bar should travel up the shins to the knees. Once the bar has traveled to the knees, one must make an effort to lock out the hips by engaging the glutes.
The tables show EMG data collected by Fauth et. al comparing common strength and conditioning activities . The deadlift is the king of hamstring activation taking the top spot in both the BF and ST, during the eccentric and concentric portions.
According to the research the two handed kettlebell swing is the top way to develop the BF and a great way to foster proper hip hinge. The kettlebell swing is a dynamic activity, a potential drawback or benefit, and has a relatively high learning curve. A difficult, dynamic activity was chosen because of its implications for fostering increases in rate of force development (RFD) by placing a high demand during the early portion (50-100ms) of the exercise. In a study comparing romanian deadlift and kettlebell swings, the swing outperformed the romanian deadlift in BF activity. As seen by Contreras, et al., manipulating load during the kettlebell swing affects EMG amplitude . A subject was evaluated at 16, 28, and 48kgs. Amplitudes increased linearly in response to the corresponding weight: more weight equaled more EMG amplitude. This phenomenon is not only found in kettlebells, as high intensity weight training: 85-95% of 1rm creates high muscle activation. In the same study, the Gmax was analysed and had almost as much activation as BF, and the vastus lateralis was analysed and actually outperformed the BF and GMax. Therefore, the KBS can be used to develop the whole posterior chain including: Erector Spinae, gluteus maximus, and BF, and ST while also developing the vastus lateralis [11, 14]. The added benefit of being a ballistic activity has implications for fostering increases in RFD. Thus, its ballistic nature has a potentially challenging learning curve, and care should be taken during the exercise because of the potentially high shearing forces on the lower spinal joints. When repetitions are done in a hip hinge manner, rather than a “squat style swing”, a pull should be felt in the hamstring and the action should be completed by locking the hips. Essentially, the movement represents the conventional deadlift but the resistance instrument allows you to ergonomically place it between the legs.
This data, collected by Schmitt et. al, compares BF emg amplitude amongst multiple exercises to the prone lying curl – a common hamstring activity marked by the solid black line . The KBS ranks highest in terms of BF activity.
EMG ANALYSIS OF LOWER EXTREMITY MUSCLE RECRUITMENT PATTERNS DURING OPEN KINETIC CHAIN AND CLOSED KINETIC CHAIN EXERCISES
Neuromuscular Activation of the Vastus Intermedius Muscle during Isometric Hip Flexion
Relationships among Vertical Jumping Performance, EMG Activation, and Knee Extensor and Flexor Muscle Strength in Turkish Elite Male Volleyball Players
In vivo load sharing among the quadriceps components
Activation of quadriceps femoris including vastus intermedius during fatiguing dynamic knee extensions
Kinematic and Electromyographic Activity Changes during Back Squat with Submaximal and Maximal Loading
Electromyographic Comparison of Barbell Deadlift, Hex Bar Deadlift, and Hip Thrust Exercises: A Cross-Over Study
A Comparison of Gluteus Maximus, Biceps Femoris, and Vastus Lateralis EMG Activity in the Back Squat and Barbell Hip Thrust Exercises
Effects of 6-week squat, deadlift, or hip thrust training program on speed, power, agility, and strength in experienced lifters: A pilot study
Kettlebell Swings: Go Heavier For Greater Glute And Hamstring Activation
What Is the Best Exercise for the Hamstrings?
HAMSTRINGS, QUADRICEPS, AND GLUTEAL MUSCLE ACTIVATION DURING RESISTANCE TRAINING EXERCISES
Muscle Activation During Various Hamstring Exercises
Kettlebell swing targets semitendinosus and supine leg curl targets biceps femoris: an EMG study with rehabilitation implications
Towards evidence based strength training: a comparison of muscle forces during deadlifts, goodmornings and split squats
ELECTROMYOGRAPHIC ANALYSIS OF GLUTEUS MEDIUS AND GLUTEUS MAXIMUS DURING REHABILITATION EXERCISES
Strengthening the Gluteus Medius Using Various Bodyweight and Resistance Exercises
Does the Dumbbell-Carrying Position Change the Muscle Activity in Split Squats and Walking Lunges?
Electromyographic Analysis of Hip and Knee Exercises: a Continuum from Early Rehabilitation to Enhancing Performance
An electromyographic and kinetic comparison of conventional and Romanian deadlifts
An electromyographic analysis of sumo and conventional style deadlifts
Muscle activation during lower body resistance training
Can you “just squat” for maximal leg development?
Muscle Activity in Single- vs. Double-Leg Squats
The Effects of a Weight Belt on Trunk and Leg Muscle Activity and Joint Kinematics During the Squat Exercise
MUSCLE ACTIVATION IN THE LOADED FREE BARBELL SQUAT: A BRIEF REVIEW
EMG Analysis of Trunk and Lower Limb Muscles in Three Different Squat Exercises in Athletes and Non-Athletes
EMG evaluation of hip adduction exercises for soccer players: implications for exercise selection in prevention and treatment of groin injuries
Activation of the hip adductor muscles varies during a simulated weight-bearing task
Posted on June 5, 2019 at 1:02 PM by Vanda Meehan
In an effort to save the natural lifter time and energy, I’m going to pick two exercises which have the highest muscle activation in the lower body. Unless you’re a juice up horse with a needle in your butt, you don’t need to spend two hours in the gym to maximize efficiency. Once you trigger muscle protein synthesis, it’s time to leave the gym. The idea that a natural lifter needs 20 sets of 5 different exercises all targeting the same muscle group is misguided time wasting. I will try my best to avoid choosing the same exercise in different muscle categories. Five categories will be considered: the quadriceps, hamstrings, glutes, hip adductors, and hip flexors. Exercises will be evaluated by their electromyographical (EMG) amplitude. EMG is recorded by placing electrodes on muscle groups in an effort to record electrical impulses. EMG can be described as the study of electricity in muscles. More specifically, EMG amplitude is a measure of motor unit activity during muscle action. It’s described as an evaluation of muscle tension or how hard a muscle becomes during exercise. EMG comes with a set of limitations: cross talk, interference, placement error, muscle fatigue, technique, etc. Researchers plan for this and typically make every effort to avoid these limitations.
Colloquially called the thigh, the quadriceps are so named for it’s comprised of four muscles. The vastus medius (VM) lies on the inside of the thigh and connects to the knee joints. The vastus lateralis (VL) runs up the outside of both thighs. The rectus femoris (RF) and vastus intermedius (VI) run up the middle of the thigh on top of the femur connecting the hip to the knee.
For the quadriceps, I picked the lunge and the leg extension. It’s the ultimate blend of closed chain and open chain. All of the weaknesses of the leg extension are addressed with the lunge and vice versa. Multiple studies report the lunge having nearly equal EMG amplitude of the vastus lateralis and medialis, but rectus femoris activation leaves something to be desired.
The barbell lunge outperforms the squat in VL and VM EMG amplitude, yet it’s one of the least common exercise you will see in the gym. Everyone seems to be obsessed with dumbell walking lunges, a gross replacement for the barbell variation. Firstly, the barbell lunge should be a relatively stationary activity. The participant should stand on one leg, kick the other leg back and inhibit its contribution to the activity. In reality, the activity would be better named the unilateral squat, as the rear foot/leg should play only a support or balance role: it’s a one legged squat. It’s an activity that requires the hip, knee, and ankle joints to work simultaneously. Because it’s compound, the lunge activates numerous muscle groups: the quads, glutes, adductors, calves, and low back. The barbell lunge develops the VL and VM greater than any exercise, while activating the RF to lesser degree. Considering the quadriceps muscle group makes up the most mass in the human body, it’s an important choice. The barbell lunge has the capability to be loaded progressively, it is a compound exercise, it challenges the back and abdominals, it requires upper back strength, and it challenges balance. There is an added benefit of having around 50% the weight a barbell squat would. And believe me, I’m not trying to bash the squat. I had originally chosen the squat as my first choice, but the research kept showing the lunge ahead of the squat in EMG activity. As much as I love the squat, I couldn’t deny the multiple studies all recording the lunge ahead of the squat in VM and VL amplitude.
This study conducted by Faith et. al, compared four exercises across multiple lower extremity muscle groups . The researchers data shows that the lunge had the highest degree of VL and VM activity . The lunge, step-up and squat are all great developers of the leg and the goal of looking at the research is to not play favorites.
My second choice for the quadriceps group is the leg extension machine. The constant tension of a machine contrasts the nature of free weights and it’s the best way to develop the RF. These two activities fit together extremely well as they supplement each other’s weakness. The leg extension doesn’t force as much VM and VL activation as the lunge, but develops the rectus femoris unlike any other activity. One study which analysed the leg extension at different knee angles found that the RF is most activated at near full extension, when the exercise is most difficult. This is likely the reason why lunge has less RF activity, considering, during the lunge, the exercise gets progressively easier as the knee nears full extension. The leg extension activity also develops the VI. Understanding VI’s location elucidates the difficulty in finding an appropriate activation, as it sits hidden underneath the rectus femoris and lies atop the femur bone. Nevertheless, some research has been conducted on the muscle . It appears to be activated by the leg extension machine to a greater degree than any of the three other quadriceps muscles at a lower knee angle: 90-115, and dwindles at higher knee angles. Therefore, the leg extension machine may be considered “better” than the lunge for total quadriceps development, if you are a bodybuilder. It certainly activates all four of the quadriceps muscle (no research was found regarding barbell lunges and VI activation) in a relatively even manner, whereas doing lunges will emphasize the VM and VL. The leg extension is absolutely 100% safe for the ACL and will not make it more susceptible to injury; knee pain during the activity it is likely the patellar joint.
The data collected by Ebben et. al, compared five extremely common lower body activities . The data shows the leg extension exercise having the highest peak and average RF emg activity.
EMG ANALYSIS OF LOWER EXTREMITY MUSCLE RECRUITMENT PATTERNS DURING OPEN KINETIC CHAIN AND CLOSED KINETIC CHAIN EXERCISES